Anderson W. “Andy” Benenhaley, 77, died Wednesday, February 22, 2023, at Prisma Health Tuomey Hospital. Born in Sumter, he was a son of the late Luther Benenhaley and Alice Hess Benenhaley. Mr. Benenhaley was a self-employed construction worker. Surviving is a son, Scott Watson of Yorktown, VA; a sister, Alice Massengill; a brother, Belford Benenhaley; several grandchildren; several nieces and nephews and a good friend and fishing buddy, Richard Benenhaley who was closer than a brother. Andy’s family want to say “thank you Richard” for always being there for Andy. He was preceded in death by brothers, Frank, Luther and Harry Benenhaley. Online condolences may be made at www.sumterfunerals.com Elmore Hill McCreight Funeral Home & Crematory, 221 Broad Street, Sumter, is in charge of the arrangements (803) 775-9386.